Excessive Celebration Penalties Have Now Gone Too Far


I’m officially sick and tired of the excessive celebration penalty in football, and now it has reached the high-school level. Boston Cathedral QB Matthew Owens ran for a 56-yard touchdown and looked to have the go-ahead score late in the 4th quarter against Blue Hills. Everything about the play was fine….except the part where he raised his fist in the air at about the 20 yard line. Just like in college football, celebrating before scoring a touchdown not only costs you 15 yards, but the touchdown is taken away.

Here is the play in question:

Owens, a senior playing on his 18th birthday, threw an interception on the very next play and Blue Hills would go on to win the game and the state title.

I’m sick of this. There is nothing in that video to suggest anything other than pure excitement of scoring the potential game-winning touchdown for your school. Raising your fist isn’t some sort of taunt like the official college football rules state:

“If the ball is alive when the player makes a taunting gesture, then the penalty is enforced at the spot of the foul – and the key outcome: no touchdown.’’

ARE YOU KIDDING ME?! A taunting penalty, which is almost certainly a subjective call and is at the referee’s discretion, is treated the same as a holding or clipping call?

I cannot really be angry at the referees as they’re being instructed to do as they’re told, but I can be pissed off at the new rules and this new era of “controlling your emotions” in sports. Basically the NFL and NCAA decided to lump anything that could be deemed as a gesture into one gigantic bucket and will flag you relentlessly. These are not gang signs, obscene gestures, choreographed dances, simulated sex acts, etc. It’s the raising of a fist whilst running in stride and five yards in the clear!

You don’t see baseball changing the rules to take away a home run if you celebrate excessively, do you? As long as you touch all of the bases you can celebrate how you want. Goals scored in soccer always stand and at worst you get a yellow card for taking off your shirt or going into the stands. Football at a collegiate and high school level is the only sport I can think of where a legal scoring play is taken away because of a celebratory gesture. I’m done with this stupid stupid celebration topic. There is no argument to be made for the rules the NCAA has put in place.

I firmly believe there is an underlying cause to all of these befuddling decisions. This is following a long pattern of the “Self-Esteem Movement”. Dodgeball is banned in select schools across the country due to the fear of someone getting hurt or “feeling targeted”. A Virginia school actually banned tag and touch football! All of these schools hide behind the fear of lawsuit, as well. If that’s the case then they must have no money in their budget to hire an average rent-a-lawyer, because parents who sue the school because their kid got hurt playing dodgeball should have no case in court.

I’ve already gone through childhood and managed as much dodgeball, football, tag, and other rough-and-tumble games that are being taken away. I’ve taunted, been taunted, celebrated early, gotten the odd scrape and bruises, and survived. I’ll be damned if this stupid nanny state is going to seep into the high school, college, and professional ranks of sport.

End this insanity, please!



4 thoughts on “Excessive Celebration Penalties Have Now Gone Too Far

  1. Anonymous

    I think they should strengthen the rule and enforce it even more strictly. Otherwise you end up with the ludicrous antics you see in the AFL. It’s disgusting how these idiots jump around and act like a bunch of jackasses when they make a tackle. Every time they do these elaborately choreographed dances I want to puke. It’s completely classless baloney and it makes me very happy when it’s called. These idiots have been warned repeatedly about excessive celebration and if they endanger their team’s fortunes by insisting on unsportsmanlike displays, then so be it.

    1. Anonymous

      Some rules are ok, especially for really tasteless like fake mooning the crowd or something and could be treated differently. Even then, I’m not sure if I would go as far as taking away the TD. However, if the other options are back the kickoff up 10-15 yards, then maybe take it away and penalize from the spot of the foul for really tasteless taunting and celebrations, and for not so bad ones, just enforce on the kickoff. Something like this, no way, too far.

  2. Anonymous

    in this sport you should be able to celebrate all you want this a spor that requires skill strength and a good american heart to play. When you are playing and you hit someone for a win think about it are you going to stand up and jump and yell for your team and be happy or are you going to sit there and say yay and go on that is not cool at all people like to see this tell me that you are not going to get pumped after you get a winning score in football a huge tackle for the win or a catch for a huge gain that is what this sport is about winning and celebrating on what you have done in this game you will automatically stand up at any time and yell ya you get flaged for it but that rule should be taken away because you arent going to be able to stop some one from celebrating a touchdown its just how it is in the game of football.


Sound off.....

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s